+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10

Wave Particle Duality

This is a discussion on Wave Particle Duality within the Science General Discussion forums, part of the Science category; -This is long. I will need to edit it, I bet. There might be typo's poor grammar and mistakes. I ...

  1. #1
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brownsburg, Indiana
    Country
    This is AntiTheist's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Anti-Theist
    Posts
    14

    Talking Wave Particle Duality

    -This is long. I will need to edit it, I bet. There might be typo's poor grammar and mistakes. I am tired and will edit later. - Kiefer presented me with a link on physics in the evolution form Subject: Intelligent design. Based on my research I disagree with his conclusion below:
    The double slit experiment worked the way it did because when not being observed, the electron goes through both, neither, and each single one of the slits at the same time and interferes with itself to create the wave like interference pattern. When observed it does not, because any act of measurement disturbs the electrons and thus destroys the interference pattern. This is possible because electrons move so quickly that they can, for a brief amount of time, exist in multiple places at once.

    I highly suggest this websites videos on Physics, Relativity, Quantum Mechanics, and Standard Model for further information. It can get a little annoying at times, but the information is very interesting.
    This video would be an outstanding resource for 9th - 12th grade students with an interest in Quantum Mechanics. As you know analogies are not intended to substitute for real world; the same goes for cartoons - Roadrunner comes to mind . I recently made this mistake with "Dr.Quantum".

    The word observed only seems used in "popular" text or when speaking to an audience which lacks an 8 year degree like myself. More frequently I have found a word similar to '
    interaction' (interaction with the object or 'interference' from the interaction of the object measuring it.) This is what causes the change in this experiment NOT 'observation.
    • http://web.phys.ksu.edu/vqmorig/tutorials/online/prep/ - double slit at home The form of the wave-function in the double slit experiment will be radically different if only one slit is open compared to both slits being open. So even for a single interaction the likely position of an interaction on the screen depends on whether both slits are open or not.

    I would like to stop for a second?

    This is possible because electrons move so quickly that they can, for a brief amount of time, exist in multiple places at once.
    It is interesting you bring this up. I am not sure what you are referring to here. I have read no scientific study which has arrived at this conclusion. Possibly I need to read much more. But this speed or 'ability' to be in many places at once suggests omnipresence. Quantum Entanglement is the ability for the most basic building blocks of everything to interact over any distance instantly as if space-time did not exist. This is something I know less about. However, it interests the heck out of me.
    *I realize there is most likely a physical explanation for this. I playfully said possibly it demonstrates some form of intelligence in a previous post. There are many people who believe and make very good arguments suggesting these most basic building blocks of life are intelligent and we can interact with them. The best known example is:
    http://www.whatthebleep.com/index2.shtml
    It is strange shit. I am more compelled to believe there is no type of human interaction or connection to the quantum world. But, it you have not check it out
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    An electron is either a particle or a wave. In the physical world we see unless you were an very very rare birth or take medication/had surgery you are either male or you either are female. A particle is a particle and a wave is a wave. It is my understanding in this physical world/dimension we play in "it is what it is". You can not be both a male and a female. A gun is not a pen it is a gun. A particle is not a wave - it is a particle.

    Definitions of particle on the Web:

    * atom: (nontechnical usage) a tiny piece of anything
    * a body having finite mass and internal structure but negligible dimensions
    * a function word that can be used in English to form phrasal verbs
    Definitions of wave on the Web:

    * one of a series of ridges that moves across the surface of a liquid (especially across a large body of water)
    * a movement like that of a sudden occurrence or increase in a specified phenomenon; "a wave of settlers"; "troops advancing in waves"
    * (physics) a movement up and down or back and forth
    * something that rises rapidly; "a wave of emotion swept over him"; "there was a sudden wave of buying before the market closed"; "a wave of conservatism in the country led by the hard right"
    Again, in the world we see, live in and interact with a wave is a wave. A particle is a particle. Uniformity in nature allows science to differentiate 'this'(wave) from that(particle). Here is just a random quote about an electron which demonstrates it can not be both at once:
    When we were discussing electric currents, and resistances, we viewed the electrons as tiny point particles with a certain mass and electric charge. Resistance was then said to arise from the collisions of electrons with other particles in a wire. This view of the electron as a particle is certainly correct in this situation; the electron here cannot be thought of as a wave.
    modtech@theory.uwinnipeg.ca
    You were somewhat correct. It is interference from our attempt to measure it that 'changes' the electron. However, here are the labs conducting the study with their results rather than cartoons or 'popular' explainations
    and another lab that has conducted such tests
    It is the interference/non interference which is responsible for the queerness of the electron not the speed:
    The interactions are not provoked by the particle itself but by the force carriers that it
    emits (generally the virtual photons). When a detector detects an electron, it does not
    really “touch” the electron or even “see” it, it interacts with its electromagnetic field
    (with its virtual photons). The electron is emitting continuously a cloud of virtual photons that surrounds it.


    During this experiment we actually never see the electron, as described in the link above, our attempt to measure them 'disrupts' them. On this scale.... On this level demonstrated time and time again some of the most basic building blocks have the ability to be both a wave and a particle. The interaction, interference or observation(poor word) can 'change' the electron. On a quantum scale the basic building blocks of life can be this or that. They can violate the law I mentioned before: "It is what it is".

    The truth is we do not fully understand this crazy stuff yet. Like god rushes in to fill these gaps pseudo-science/zen science(What The Bleep Do We Know) rushes in to fill the gaps.

    It is my understanding modern science believes this ability to be a wave or a particle in the quantum world is wave-particle duality:

    Quantum Physics is tricky. The information which is intended for people without the background to understand is not intentionally misleading. However, much of the information which is presented is very watered down.

    I present this guy as an example. He is 'the grand-dad' of some important stuff relevant to this topic. In much if not all of his research he will not slow down if you to not have the background to follow along. Even if you do most still fall short:
    [YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/v/_7OEzyEfzgg&hl=en&fs=1&[/YOUTUBE]
    So, the quantum world violates much of the reality our world can not. I understand this also where the string theory begins. Like the w/p duality the string theory suggests particles with pure potential to be this, that, that or this pending on their unique vibration.

    Anything to add? Change? All this is WEIRD!
    Last edited by AntiTheist; 07-06-2009 at 11:42 PM. Reason: Kiefer presented me with a link on physics in the evolution form Subject: Intelligent design

  2. #2
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brownsburg, Indiana
    Country
    This is AntiTheist's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Anti-Theist
    Posts
    14

    Wink Re: Wave Particle Duality

    This is an amazing field. Anyone with information or 'direction' if I am misguided is welcome.

  3. #3
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Halton Region
    Country
    This is Louis's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    None
    Posts
    463

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Hawkings' books for lay people are great resources. He goes into some detail about the double slit experiment in "A Briefer History of Time". His "The Universe in a Nutshell" contains the latest on quantum theory. Highly accessible books on complicated subjects. I recommend.

  4. #4
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brownsburg, Indiana
    Country
    This is AntiTheist's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Anti-Theist
    Posts
    14

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Quote Originally Posted by Louis View Post
    Hawkings' books for lay people are great resources. He goes into some detail about the double slit experiment in "A Briefer History of Time". His "The Universe in a Nutshell" contains the latest on quantum theory. Highly accessible books on complicated subjects. I recommend.
    There is tons of material on it for me the lay person. I've looked at a lot of it and understand some of it. After looking at my message it was long. Although a little confusing I presented the information I am reviewing in attempt to better understand this specific topic/concept.

    In the quantum world, the one which holds the most basic building blocks of everything, the laws that describe(apply to) our physical world do not apply there. With that said the laws in our are correct and work just fine. That is odd in itself.

    An electron or the 'things' which make up an electron have the ability(some say potential) to be 2 thing. When it is measured the interference from the measurement 'disturbs' it. This 'changes' it into a particle (collapsing) the wave function or vice-versa.

    My dog can not change into a cat. An acorn if planted turns into a tree. A planted acorn will never 'grow into' a theist. It does not have the ability/potential to do anything else. The laws(natural/physical) that govern the acorn command it to act a specific way. Electrons are 'allowed' to make changes we are not - they do so with no regard to 'our' law.

    What we define as impossible takes place in the quantum world. How is that possible LOL.

    This is my understanding. Is it correct? Is this really how it is? My only choice to continue study here is to drop what I know and accept the facts of research? How do you understand it
    Last edited by AntiTheist; 07-07-2009 at 08:09 PM. Reason: nor to not

  5. #5
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brownsburg, Indiana
    Country
    This is AntiTheist's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Anti-Theist
    Posts
    14

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Oh, I can not edit? For clarity sake - then I will STFU.

    The previous message is what I take away from the double slit. Is there more I should understand? I do not have the formal schooling / education to understand the mechanisms or math that actually makes this all work.

    I do though drive my car and do not fully understand everything that is going on in my engine. I do not know how my computer work - it is all 0 & 1's on a very basic level. But, I know how to use my computer fine. I seek this same understanding, more might come later. I know this is not a physics forum but. . .

  6. #6
    Super Moderator Kiefer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Calgary Alberta
    Country
    This is Kiefer's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Atheist
    Pol. View
    Liberal/Socialist
    Posts
    838

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    -This is long. I will need to edit it, I bet. There might be typo's poor grammar and mistakes. I am tired and will edit later.
    Just going to mention here that there's a time limit on how long you have before you can't edit anymore. I think it's ~15mins.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    The word observed only seems used in "popular" text or when speaking to an audience which lacks an 8 year degree like myself.
    I'm confused, over and over you claim to have only a basic readers knowledge of the topics, then you say you have an eight year degree?

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    It is interesting you bring this up. I am not sure what you are referring to here. I have read no scientific study which has arrived at this conclusion. Possibly I need to read much more.
    Once you get passed the "childish" (for lack of a better word) elements of the videos, they cover this topic.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    But this speed or 'ability' to be in many places at once suggests omnipresence. Quantum Entanglement is the ability for the most basic building blocks of everything to interact over any distance instantly as if space-time did not exist.
    No it doesn't, it suggests the ability to move so fast that it can exist, for a fraction of a fraction of a second, in two places at once. It's possible that to do this, it is slipping into another dimension before reentering ours.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    *I realize there is most likely a physical explanation for this. I playfully said possibly it demonstrates some form of intelligence in a previous post.
    I didn't catch the "playfulness" of your tone, the downfall of internet discussions.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    An electron is either a particle or a wave. In the physical world we see unless you were an very very rare birth or take medication/had surgery you are either male or you either are female. A particle is a particle and a wave is a wave. It is my understanding in this physical world/dimension we play in "it is what it is". You can not be both a male and a female. A gun is not a pen it is a gun. A particle is not a wave - it is a particle.
    As you yourself said however, things at a Quantum level do not follow our laws. There is no reason to think that an electron could not behave as a wave in one instance and a particle in another. That's not to say that when it happen, it's not the very very rare birth of a Quantum hermaphrodite however.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    You were somewhat correct. It is interference from our attempt to measure it that 'changes' the electron. However, here are the labs conducting the study with their results rather than cartoons or 'popular' explainations
    I find it absolutely hilarious that you criticize my link for being cartoony yet when I open yours, the first thing I see is a cartoon soldier firing a gun at two slits. That and the first one just restates the video anyways! I'll read the second one on the weekend, it's a little too heavy for me to go over right now.
    Faith, n. Belief without evidence in what is told by one who speaks without knowledge, of things without parallel.
    Religion, n. A daughter of hope and fear, explaining to ignorance the nature of the unknowable.
    Philosophy, n. A route of many roads leading from nowhere to nothing.
    -Ambrose Bierce

  7. #7
    Senior Member Kaeso's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Montréal
    Country
    This is Kaeso's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    nil
    Posts
    166

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Quote Originally Posted by Kiefer View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    The word observed only seems used in "popular" text or when speaking to an audience which lacks an 8 year degree like myself.
    I'm confused, over and over you claim to have only a basic readers knowledge of the topics, then you say you have an eight year degree?
    Hmm... That confused me too, but I think what he meant was that he is one of the people lacking an 8 year degree; he could have put it this way: "...or when speaking to an audience, like myself, which lacks an 8 year degree."
    "Dimidium facti qui coepit habet: sapere aude: incipe." --Quintus Horatius Flaccus

  8. #8
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brownsburg, Indiana
    Country
    This is AntiTheist's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Anti-Theist
    Posts
    14

    Red face Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Quote Originally Posted by Kiefer View Post
    Just going to mention here that there's a time limit on how long you have before you can't edit anymore. I think it's ~15mins.



    I'm confused, over and over you claim to have only a basic readers knowledge of the topics, then you say you have an eight year degree?



    Once you get passed the "childish" (for lack of a better word) elements of the videos, they cover this topic.



    No it doesn't, it suggests the ability to move so fast that it can exist, for a fraction of a fraction of a second, in two places at once. It's possible that to do this, it is slipping into another dimension before reentering ours.



    I didn't catch the "playfulness" of your tone, the downfall of internet discussions.



    As you yourself said however, things at a Quantum level do not follow our laws. There is no reason to think that an electron could not behave as a wave in one instance and a particle in another. That's not to say that when it happen, it's not the very very rare birth of a Quantum hermaphrodite however.



    I find it absolutely hilarious that you criticize my link for being cartoony yet when I open yours, the first thing I see is a cartoon soldier firing a gun at two slits. That and the first one just restates the video anyways! I'll read the second one on the weekend, it's a little too heavy for me to go over right now.

    "No it doesn't, it suggests the ability to move so fast that it can exist, for a fraction of a fraction of a second, in two places at once. It's possible that to do this, it is slipping into another dimension before reentering ours. "

    Can you tell me where I should obtain more information on theory/concept? I am interested.

    "As you yourself said however, things at a Quantum level do not follow our laws. There is no reason to think that an electron could not behave as a wave in one instance and a particle in another. That's not to say that when it happen, it's not the very very rare birth of a Quantum hermaphrodite however. "

    That is absolutely fascinating though isn't it? That the impossible in the world we interact with is possible in the invisible, possibly rightfully considered beyond microscopic, realm of the quantum world? Yet, this quantum world is where the most basic building blocks of life are found. It violates everything we know, yet is responsible for everything we know. Even professional researchers often admit such concepts are difficult for them to grasp. Brian Greene & Brian Cox often state this with clarity.


    "I'm confused, over and over you claim to have only a basic readers knowledge of the topics, then you say you have an eight year degree?"

    This post seemed more like an attack. I guess you are just pissed about the cartoon comment. Can I retract it? I apologize I wish to look into this with just more than one reference - cartoon or not. You made no effort to address any of my questions. You did attempt to pull apart non-relevant parts of my post on more than one occasion.

    I am not sure where to go from here? If there is an interest in sharing your knowledge to help myself and others better understand lets push on.

  9. #9
    Super Moderator Kiefer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Calgary Alberta
    Country
    This is Kiefer's Country Flag
    Gender
    Male
    Belief
    Atheist
    Pol. View
    Liberal/Socialist
    Posts
    838

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    Can you tell me where I should obtain more information on theory/concept? I am interested.
    Most of my information comes from those videos, and a couple of YouTube users. I'll openly admit that I'm no expert on the topics however.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    That is absolutely fascinating though isn't it? That the impossible in the world we interact with is possible in the invisible, possibly rightfully considered beyond microscopic, realm of the quantum world? Yet, this quantum world is where the most basic building blocks of life are found. It violates everything we know, yet is responsible for everything we know. Even professional researchers often admit such concepts are difficult for them to grasp. Brian Greene & Brian Cox often state this with clarity.
    Yes it is fascinating, to put it lightly. Advances in Quantum Mechanics have the potential to completely re write science as we know it.

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiTheist View Post
    This post seemed more like an attack. I guess you are just pissed about the cartoon comment. Can I retract it? I apologize I wish to look into this with just more than one reference - cartoon or not. You made no effort to address any of my questions. You did attempt to pull apart non-relevant parts of my post on more than one occasion.
    That was not meant as an attack in any way, I am genuinely confused and seeking an answer to the question.

    On an off note, do you think you could refrain from using bold, italic, and underline on your entire post? It makes responding a clusterfuck.
    Faith, n. Belief without evidence in what is told by one who speaks without knowledge, of things without parallel.
    Religion, n. A daughter of hope and fear, explaining to ignorance the nature of the unknowable.
    Philosophy, n. A route of many roads leading from nowhere to nothing.
    -Ambrose Bierce

  10. #10
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Country
    This is mathkills's Country Flag
    Belief
    Humanist
    Posts
    13

    Default Re: Wave Particle Duality

    The double slit experiment alone is not enough to gain a sufficient understanding of the quantum nature of particles. I recomend also looking at EPR paradox experiments as well as Stern-Gerlach. This can help, but ultimately as was pointed out above, metaphor and analogy only goes so far. Additionally your intuition is classical and not meant to understand quantum mechanics. So if you really want to understand it (as much as possible anyway) the only way is to really learn it...

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts