"Fantasy Island" or similar

Per this thread, perhaps we could consider a "Fantasy Island" section of the forum, where chronic wasters of time, proselytizers, and unrepentant trolls could be banished. This would let adult discussion carry on between sensible atheists and theists, without the threat of being derailed by continuous pointless nonsense.

With such a section, we needn't ban such abusers outright. They could be sensibly contained in their own little area, where regulars could feed them, and generally vent their frustrations on them without disturbing real conversations elsewhere.

Originally Posted by Louis

perhaps we could consider a "Fantasy Island" section of the forum, where

chronic wasters of time,
proselytizers, and
unrepentant trolls

could be banished.

This would let adult discussion carry on between sensible atheists and theists,
without the threat of being derailed by continuous pointless nonsense.

With such a section, we needn't ban such abusers outright.

They could be sensibly contained in their own little area, where regulars could feed them, and generally vent their frustrations on them without disturbing real conversations elsewhere.

You mean, those who are genunie trolls, as well as those whom you are incapable of handling intellectually, they would be free to express themselves in the proposred section?

I like this idea.

It will expose either their absurdity, or, your fear of their superior intellect.

I cant think of a third outcome.

Originally Posted by Kiefer

I like this idea. Should we give such people a second chance if they show promise in this area?

If it were up to me, no. Warn all you like, but once they're in, they're in.

Woo-hoo. And you used the best name too, although the Shire is more real to a geek like me than Fantasy Island or Heaven. Thanks.